This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
Asset 3
  • About
  • People
  • Capabilities
  • Insights
  • Careers
  • Public Interest
  • Inclusion
  • Contact us
    Contact us
  • Locations
    Locations
  • Search
    Search
  • About
    • About
    • Message From the CEO
    • Firm History
    • Alumni
    • Alumni
    • In Memoriam
  • People
  • Capabilities
    • Practices
    • Industries
    • Global Reach: The Law Firm Network
    • Bankruptcy & Restructuring
    • Brand & Reputation Management
    • Intellectual Property
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Special Situations, Distressed Debt and Debt Trading
    • Transactions
    • Tax
    • White Collar Defense, Investigations & Compliance
    • Energy & Environmental
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Investment Management 
    • Life Sciences
    • Technology
    • Real Estate
    • Bankruptcy & Restructuring
    • Bankruptcy Litigation
    • Mass Torts Bankruptcy
    • Intellectual Property
    • Intellectual Property Litigation
    • Patents
    • Trademark, Copyright & Advertising
    • Patent Trial and Appeals Board (PTAB)
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Civil Fraud Litigation
    • Employment Practices and Litigation
    • Government Contracts Litigation
    • Intellectual Property Litigation
    • Insurance Recovery
    • Litigation Funding
    • M&A and Private Equity Litigation
    • Real Estate Litigation
    • Patent Trial and Appeals Board (PTAB)
    • UK Tax Controversy & Litigation
    • Special Situations, Distressed Debt and Debt Trading
    • Distressed Debt & Claims Trading
    • Litigation Funding
    • Finance
    • Real Estate Special Situations
    • Transactions
    • Capital Markets
    • Cross-Border Transactions
    • Emerging Growth Companies & Venture Capital
    • Employment
    • Finance
    • Franchising
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Tax
    • White Collar Defense, Investigations & Compliance
    • Economic Sanctions & Export Controls
    • Energy & Environmental
    • Energy
    • Energy Transition
    • Environmental
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Brand & Reputation Management
    • Intellectual Property
    • Sports
    • Investment Management
    • Fund Formation
    • Private Equity Transactions
    • Distressed Debt
    • Emerging Growth Companies & Venture Capital
    • Family-Owned & Closely Held Businesses
    • Private Equity Litigation
    • Life Sciences
    • BR BioAdvisory Services
    • Technology
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cybersecurity & Data Privacy
    • Digital Commerce
    • Fintech
    • Real Estate
    • Hospitality & Leisure
    • Distressed Real Estate
    • Real Estate Special Situations
    • Real Estate Litigation
    • Wireless Network Infrastructure
  • Insights
    • Client News
    • Firm News
    • Briefings
    • Events
  • Careers
    • Experienced Lawyers
    • U.S. Law Students
    • London Trainee Program
    • Business Professionals
    • Professional Development
  • Public Interest
    • Brown Rudnick Charitable Foundation
    • Pro Bono & Community Service
  • Inclusion
    • Inclusion
    • Women in Business Series
  • Contact Us
  • Location
  • Search
  • About
    • About
    • Message From the CEO
    • Firm History
    • Alumni
    • Alumni
    • In Memoriam
  • People
  • Capabilities
    • Practices
    • Industries
    • Global Reach: The Law Firm Network
    • Bankruptcy & Restructuring
    • Brand & Reputation Management
    • Intellectual Property
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Special Situations, Distressed Debt and Debt Trading
    • Transactions
    • Tax
    • White Collar Defense, Investigations & Compliance
    • Energy & Environmental
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Investment Management 
    • Life Sciences
    • Technology
    • Real Estate
    • Bankruptcy & Restructuring
    • Bankruptcy Litigation
    • Mass Torts Bankruptcy
    • Intellectual Property
    • Intellectual Property Litigation
    • Patents
    • Trademark, Copyright & Advertising
    • Patent Trial and Appeals Board (PTAB)
    • Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Civil Fraud Litigation
    • Employment Practices and Litigation
    • Government Contracts Litigation
    • Intellectual Property Litigation
    • Insurance Recovery
    • Litigation Funding
    • M&A and Private Equity Litigation
    • Real Estate Litigation
    • Patent Trial and Appeals Board (PTAB)
    • UK Tax Controversy & Litigation
    • Special Situations, Distressed Debt and Debt Trading
    • Distressed Debt & Claims Trading
    • Litigation Funding
    • Finance
    • Real Estate Special Situations
    • Transactions
    • Capital Markets
    • Cross-Border Transactions
    • Emerging Growth Companies & Venture Capital
    • Employment
    • Finance
    • Franchising
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Tax
    • White Collar Defense, Investigations & Compliance
    • Economic Sanctions & Export Controls
    • Energy & Environmental
    • Energy
    • Energy Transition
    • Environmental
    • Entertainment & Media
    • Brand & Reputation Management
    • Intellectual Property
    • Sports
    • Investment Management
    • Fund Formation
    • Private Equity Transactions
    • Distressed Debt
    • Emerging Growth Companies & Venture Capital
    • Family-Owned & Closely Held Businesses
    • Private Equity Litigation
    • Life Sciences
    • BR BioAdvisory Services
    • Technology
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Cybersecurity & Data Privacy
    • Digital Commerce
    • Fintech
    • Real Estate
    • Hospitality & Leisure
    • Distressed Real Estate
    • Real Estate Special Situations
    • Real Estate Litigation
    • Wireless Network Infrastructure
  • Insights
    • Client News
    • Firm News
    • Briefings
    • Events
  • Careers
    • Experienced Lawyers
    • U.S. Law Students
    • London Trainee Program
    • Business Professionals
    • Professional Development
  • Public Interest
    • Brown Rudnick Charitable Foundation
    • Pro Bono & Community Service
  • Inclusion
    • Inclusion
    • Women in Business Series

Search People

Search by last name

A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
O
P
Q
R
S
T
U
V
W
X
Y
Z

see all people

Asset 3
  • LinkedIn
  • X (formerly known as Twitter)
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Threads
  • YouTube
  • rss
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy
  • Sitemap
  • LinkedIn
  • X (formerly known as Twitter)
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Threads
  • YouTube
  • rss

© 2024 Brown Rudnick LLP. Attorney advertising.

All Rights Reserved.

All Posts Subscribe
print-logo
4/29/2017 12:00:00 AM | 2 minute read

Has the Court of Federal Claims Relaxed its Standard for Obtaining TRO’s? Probably not.

2

Get in touch

Avatar
Brown Rudnick

Get in touch

Avatar
Brown Rudnick
2

In Continental Services Group, Inc. v United States (No. 17-449, March 29, 2017), the U.S. Department of Education issued a solicitation for the collection and administrative resolution of debts resulting from non-payment of student loans.  Continental Services (“CS”) submitted an offer.  CS was not selected for the award and, as did other disappointed bidders, filed a timely bid protest at GAO.  The protests triggered a CICA stay of performance. The CICA stay, which is automatic and mandatory, requires agencies to withhold award or suspend performance of an award upon timely notice from the GAO of a protest.  Agencies can override that stay only if there are urgent and compelling circumstances or if it is in the best interests of the United States.  GAO can’t enforce CICA stays.  So if protesters disagree with an agency’s override, they must challenge the override in the Court of Federal Claims (“COFC”).

In this case, the Department of Education did not override the CICA stay.  Instead, it began transferring the work to be performed to other contracts. That looked like an effort to circumvent the CICA stay.  Rather than challenge the agency’s actions as a violation of the CICA stay, CS withdrew its bid protest from the GAO and filed a protest at the COFC.  The COFC does not have an equivalent to the automatic CICA stay.  At the COFC, the government must either agree to a voluntary stay or the protester must obtain a temporary restraining order (“TRO”) and/or preliminary injunction.  In this case, the agency did not agree to stay performance and CS filed a motion for a TRO.

CS’s decision to file a bid protest in court rather than directly challenge the agency’s circumvention of the stay led to an interesting decision from the COFC.  Had CS challenged the Department of Education’s actions as arbitrary and a violation of the CICA stay, the COFC would have determined whether the decision to override the stay was arbitrary. But because CS filed a bid protest against the selection decision, the COFC had to consider whether to grant a TRO against continued performance of the contract that had been awarded (apart from the propriety of the override of the CICA stay).  In so doing, the COFC held that it was not in a position to consider the likelihood of success on the merits of CS’s bid protest at all.  According to the decision “since the Government has not yet produced the Administrative Record and the parties have not had an opportunity to brief the merits of this bid protest, the court is not in a position to decide Continental Services’ likelihood of success.”  Yet, the COFC still issued the TRO.  Some view this decision as easing the requirements for obtaining a TRO at the COFC, inviting more bid protests before the COFC.  Or it may be a one-off decision made in response to agency efforts to circumvent the CICA stay.  Indeed, in granting relief, the COFC specifically ordered the government to halt “transferring work to be performed under the contract at issue in this case to other contracting vehicles to circumvent or moot this bid protest…”.  Regardless, COFC judges are not bound by one another’s decisions, so there is no telling whether the reasoning in Continental Services will be applied in similar cases in the future.

To view the COFC decision, click here.

Isabel Buchanan is a UK lawyer, currently on secondment to Brown Rudnick in DC.  She is not licensed to practice in the US.

featured image

Tags

government contracts

Get in touch

Avatar
Brown Rudnick

Get in touch

Avatar
Brown Rudnick
[2025] UKUT 00124 (TCC) George Mantides Limited v HMRC: Further Ammunition for HMRC in Its Battle Against Self-Employment in Healthcare?
5/1/2025 2:34:46 PM

[2025] UKUT 00124 (TCC) George Mantides Limited v HMRC: Further Ammunition for HMRC in Its Battle Against Self-Employment in Healthcare?

By Matthew Sharp
One of the unusual aspects of the First-tier Tribunal (“FTT”) decision in Mantides (which was the subject of this appeal to the Upper...
38
38

Latest Insights

Fourth Circuit Holds That Short-Seller Report Does Not Establish Loss Causation for Securities Claims
4/9/2025 5:32:36 PM

Fourth Circuit Holds That Short-Seller Report Does Not Establish Loss Causation for Securities Claims

By Jonathan Richman
3
3
New PTAB Ruling Highlights Critical IPR Petition Requirements: Consistency Between PTAB and District Court Proceedings
3/24/2025 6:05:50 PM

New PTAB Ruling Highlights Critical IPR Petition Requirements: Consistency Between PTAB and District Court Proceedings

By Erick Robinson
7
7
Artificial Intelligence, Real Risks: How Insurance Companies Can Provide Coverage in Response to AI Washing
3/21/2025 1:20:49 PM

Artificial Intelligence, Real Risks: How Insurance Companies Can Provide Coverage in Response to AI Washing

By Darion Alexander Daniel Healy
6
6